How to Put in a Butt Plug (Beginner-Friendly, Real Tips That Actually Work)

Quick Answer

To put in a butt plug safely and comfortably, use plenty of lubricant, start with a small size, relax your muscles, and insert it slowly—never force it. If it hurts, stop, adjust, and try again later.

How to Use Butt Plugs and Butt Plug Techniques – JOUJOU

Why This Feels Difficult for Beginners (Real Talk)

If you're trying this for the first time, it's completely normal to feel unsure—or even a bit frustrated.

From real user experiences, some people spend 10–30 minutes just getting comfortable, while others can’t insert it fully at all on the first try. That’s not failure—it just means your body needs more time.

Here’s the honest truth:

  • The body doesn’t naturally lubricate this area
  • The muscles instinctively tighten when something unfamiliar happens
  • Starting too big is one of the most common mistakes

Some people even give up on their first attempt because it feels awkward or uncomfortable. That’s actually more common than most guides admit.

Choosing the Right Butt Plug (This Matters More Than You Think)

Before you even start, your choice of toy can make or break the experience.

What beginners should look for:

  • Small diameter (start around finger size)
  • Soft material (silicone is easiest)
  • Flared base (non-negotiable for safety)
  • Tapered tip (helps with gradual entry)

Beginner To Expert Trainer Set (7 Piece With Vibrator)

One real user mentioned their plug broke during insertion, which could have become dangerous if not handled carefully. Cheap or poorly designed toys can create real risks—so this step isn’t optional.

Step-by-Step: How to Put in a Butt Plug

1. Prepare Your Body (Don’t Skip This)

Preparation is the difference between “this feels okay” and “this is impossible.”

  • Go to the bathroom beforehand
  • Take a warm shower to relax muscles
  • Optional: gently clean the area

Some people even use a finger first to get used to the sensation before inserting a toy.

File:Boy anal fingering.gif - Wikimedia Commons

2. Use More Lube Than You Think You Need

This is where most beginners go wrong.

  • Apply lube to:
    • The plug
    • The surrounding area
  • Reapply if needed

The rectum doesn’t self-lubricate, so insufficient lube = discomfort or pain.

3. Start Slow (Seriously Slow)

Don’t rush this.

  • Gently press the tip against the opening
  • Pause when you feel resistance
  • Let your body adjust before going further

A helpful technique:

  • Insert a little
  • Hold for a few seconds
  • Pull back slightly
  • Repeat

This gradual approach is commonly recommended because forcing it can lead to pain or even injury.

anal plug insertion / tight,perfect asshole close up

4. Relax Your Muscles (This Is Key)

This part is more mental than physical.

Try:

  • Deep breathing
  • Slightly “pushing out” instead of clenching
  • Staying calm and patient

One user described success by relaxing and using slow circular movements instead of pushing straight in.

5. Insert Until the Base, Then Stop

Once the plug passes the widest part, it often slides in more easily.

  • Stop at the base
  • Don’t push beyond it
  • Let your body adjust

At this point, you might feel:

  • A sense of fullness
  • Mild pressure

Both are normal. Sharp pain is not.

If you're not sure which size or type to start with, choosing a beginner-friendly option can make the process much easier. Soft silicone plugs with a tapered tip are usually the most comfortable for first-time use.

Best Positions for Easier Insertion

Different positions change how your muscles respond.

Beginner-friendly options:

  • Squatting (opens the muscles naturally)
  • Lying on your side
  • One knee up, one down

Try a few and see what feels easiest for your body.

What It Should Feel Like (And What It Shouldn’t)

Normal:

  • Pressure
  • Stretching sensation
  • Slight discomfort at first

Not normal:

  • Sharp pain
  • Burning feeling
  • Feeling like something is “stuck”

If you feel pain, stop immediately. Adjust, add more lube, or try a smaller size.

The Downsides (Most Guides Don’t Tell You This)

To keep this realistic and trustworthy:

  • It can feel awkward the first few times
  • Some people never fully enjoy it—and that’s okay
  • Using the wrong size can make the experience frustrating
  • In rare cases, improper use can lead to injury

There are even reports of people needing medical help when things go wrong, especially when safety rules aren’t followed.

So yes—it can feel great for some, but it’s not universally enjoyable.

Tips That Make a Huge Difference

  • Start smaller than you think you need
  • Always use more lube than expected
  • Take breaks if needed
  • Don’t aim for “full insertion” on day one
  • Clean your toy before and after use

Progress matters more than speed.

Concise FAQ

Is it normal if I can’t insert it fully the first time?
Yes. Many beginners need multiple attempts to get comfortable.

How long should insertion take?
Anywhere from a few minutes to 30+ minutes depending on comfort level.

What if it hurts?
Stop immediately. Add more lube, relax, or switch to a smaller size.

Can I use any butt plug?
No. Always choose one with a flared base for safety.

Do I need lube every time?
Yes. This is not optional.

Is this for everyone?
No. Some people simply don’t enjoy it, and that’s completely normal.

Final Thought

If there’s one thing I’ve learned from both research and real user experiences, it’s this:

Most problems come from rushing.

Take your time, listen to your body, and treat this as a gradual process—not a one-time success test.

That mindset alone will improve your experience more than any “perfect technique.”

Back to blog