How to Train for a Huge Butt Plug

If you're dreaming of taking a huge butt plug like a champ—but right now even the small one makes you wince—you’re not alone. A lot of people start with ambitious fantasies, only to be humbled by the reality of tight muscles, nervous tension, and plugs that feel like they’re trying to split you in half.

Training your body to comfortably take a large butt plug takes time, patience, and a lot of lube. In this guide, we'll walk you through what actually works, what to avoid, and how to build up safely and confidently. No BS, no shame—just real talk from people who’ve been there.

Large Anal Toy Silicone Plug

Start Small, Go Slow

Even if your ultimate goal is to sit on a monster plug, you’ve got to start where your body is at today. Most beginners find that they can only handle the smallest toy in a starter kit—and even that can be a challenge. That’s perfectly normal.

You’re not going to “force yourself” into a bigger toy overnight. Pain, tearing, and long-term damage can happen if you push too fast. Think of it like stretching a tight muscle—slow, steady practice leads to long-term gains, not brute force.

Key Tips for Beginners:

  • Use lots of lube. Water-based is safe with all toys, but silicone-based lasts longer.

  • Don’t clench—try to push like you're pooping when inserting. This relaxes your pelvic floor.

  • Insert the smallest plug until it feels natural, then play with it. Twist it, sit on it, move around.

  • Only move up when the smaller plug slides in and out without resistance.

 

The Role of Routine

Training is not about one heroic session. It’s about regular practice over time. Using a plug just once a month won’t stretch you out—it’s consistency that makes the difference.

Think of your butt like any other muscle: it adapts through repetition.

Try This Schedule:

  • Start with 10-15 minutes, 3-4 times a week.

  • Warm up with a finger, then the smallest plug.

  • If that goes well, move to the next size up—but only go as far as feels good.

  • Keep a journal if it helps—track what works and how you feel after.

Over time, your body gets the message. You’ll be shocked at what you can take after a few weeks.

You May Also Read：

How to Choose a Butt Plug？ 

The Mental Side of Stretching

Some people can take bigger toys when playing with a partner than they can alone. That’s not magic—it’s mental.

When you’re relaxed, turned on, and trusting the person you're with, your body opens up more easily. Stress, performance anxiety, or rushing things solo can make your muscles clamp up like a vault.

Here are ways to help your mind help your hole:

  • Set the mood. Light candles, play relaxing music, or watch something sexy.

  • Breathe deeply. Try slow, rhythmic breathing to calm your nerves.

  • Use visualization. Imagine yourself opening, welcoming the toy in.

  • Take breaks. If you feel tension or fear creeping in, stop. There’s always tomorrow.

You’re not just stretching a body part—you’re teaching your brain and body to trust the process.

Shop The Best Huge Butt Plug from Anesidora Toys 

Huge Silicone Plug

Featured Products

Tools of the Trade

When you’re working toward big plugs, not all toys are created equal. Tapered plugs are easier to insert than ones with thick bases. Dildos with gradual width increase can also help you ease in over time.

Must-Have Tools:

  • A butt plug training kit with at least 3–5 sizes

  • A long-lasting lube (consider hybrid or silicone-based if your toys allow)

  • A lube shooter to get the lube exactly where it needs to go

  • A warm-up dildo or smooth toy with a tapered shape

  • A mirror (to help you check positioning and progress)

Some experienced users also swear by products like the Fort Troff Sit-N-Stretch, which helps relax the anus with gentle sitting pressure over time. Tools like this can give your body a gentle nudge in the right direction.


What NOT to Do

Let’s be real—stretching for big toys has some risks if done wrong. Here are things you should never do:

  • Don’t force it in. Pain is a warning, not a challenge.

  • Don’t skip warm-up. Always start with a smaller size first.

  • Don’t use cheap toys. Poor-quality materials can irritate or even injure your body.

  • Don’t ignore bleeding or tearing. If this happens, stop immediately and give your body time to heal.

  • Don’t use numbing agents. They can make you ignore pain signals that are there for your safety.

Our expert put it perfectly: "It's supposed to feel GOOD." If you're gritting your teeth, you're doing it wrong.

 

What Progress Looks Like

Let’s say you're working with a 6.5 cm plug and eyeing that beastly 7.5 cm one next. If you can’t get it in fully, you might feel frustrated. But progress isn’t always linear.

Maybe you get a little deeper each week. Maybe one day it just slides in effortlessly. Or maybe you plateau for a while, then make a sudden leap.

That’s all normal.

And yes, there are people out there who can take giant toys or even fists. But they didn’t start there. Most went through weeks, months, or even years of training to get there safely.

Remember, this isn’t a race. There’s no prize for “biggest plug taken.” Your pleasure is the point.

 

Final Thoughts

Training for a huge butt plug is totally achievable—but it’s not about how tough you are. It’s about how consistent, patient, and respectful you can be with your body. The most successful stretchers are the ones who listen to their holes, not battle them.

So keep at it. Take breaks when you need to. Enjoy the journey as much as the destination. And above all—make it feel good.

Because whether you’re dreaming of getting railed like a rag doll or just want that deeply satisfying stretch, you’ve got what it takes to get there.

For More Please Read：

7 Best Silicone Butt Plugs

DIY Butt Plug

Back to blog